How the Child's Age Impacts New York Custody Cases

The age of children can play a significant role in determining the outcome of New York custody cases. New York family courts consider various factors in making decisions related to custody arrangements and parenting plans, and the age of the child could determine the amount of care necessary or the amount of input the child has on which parent gets custody.

Custody of Infants, Toddlers, and Preschool-Age Children

Infants, toddlers, and preschool-aged children have unique needs that require special attention and care. In custody cases involving very young children, the courts often prioritize their attachment to the primary caregiver. In general, the belief is that young children benefit from the security and stability offered by the primary caregiver.

For young children, the judge may also grant primary custody to the parent with whom the child has formed a stronger bond. While the court may award one parent physical custody, it will always seek to maintain the child's relationship with both parents through visitation arrangements and legal custody authority.

How the Older Child’s Opinion Can Affect Custody Rulings

As children grow older and enter the preteen and teenage years, their opinions and preferences can carry more weight in custody proceedings. Like many other states, New York recognizes the importance of including the child's perspective in custody decisions. Older children are more capable of forming their own opinions and desires regarding their living arrangements. Therefore, their wishes often receive consideration in custody determinations, especially if they are mature and capable of expressing their desires.

Unlike some U.S. states, New York does not have a specific age at which a child can independently decide custody matters. Instead, the court evaluates the child's capacity to express reasoned judgments regarding their custodial preferences. There is no magic age, but children around the age of 12 or older may have their views considered more heavily. Still, younger children might also influence the court's decision if they exhibit signs of maturity and genuinely understand the situation.

The court evaluates the credibility and reliability of the child's opinion through various mechanisms. These may include appointing a Guardian ad Litem, attorney for the child, neutral attorney, or mental health professional who independently assesses the child's preferences, conducts interviews, and submits a report with their recommendations. Moreover, the court considers the child's age, intelligence, understanding of the consequences, and whether any external influences may impact their viewpoint.

In determining the weight accorded to a child's opinion, the court considers several factors intrinsic to the child's development. These factors help ascertain the child's level of maturity, comprehension, and ability to form reasonable judgments. Factors may include the child's relationship with each parent, their capacity to articulate and justify their preferences, their emotional and physical well-being, and their understanding of the potential consequences of their choices.

In cases where the child is a teenager, the courts may also consider practical factors such as the child's educational, religious, and social needs. They may be more inclined to ensure that the child remains in their current school district or community if doing so is in their best interests.

It is crucial to underscore that while the child's opinion is considered, it is not binding. Due to the evolving nature of a child's circumstances, the court retains the power to modify or disregard a child's preferences if deemed necessary for their best interests. Therefore, parents involved in such cases need to understand that advocating for their child's welfare extends beyond simply fostering their desires but also ensuring a stable and supportive environment.

In sum, New York custody courts will often prioritize the attachment and well-being of infants while considering the input and preferences of older children. Ultimately, the courts strive to render decisions that promote the best interests of the child and provide them with a stable and nurturing environment. An experienced New York custody lawyer can help explain how your children's age may impact your case.

As custody cases unfold, parents should focus on fostering open communication, empathetic understanding, and a child-centered approach, recognizing that their child's happiness and stability should be paramount throughout this challenging process.


Naomi Schanfield

Naomi Schanfield concentrates on all aspects of matrimonial and family law, including, prenuptial and postnuptial agreements, divorce, equitable distribution, child custody and visitation, support matters, family offense disputes, and domestic violence.

To connect with Naomi: 212.682.6222 | Online

For media inquiries or speaking engagements: [hidden email]